About this episode
A strong leader is told she needs more presence, and those words go into her development plan. Presence, charisma and reading the room run on social cues, the way a good joke does, and comedy is taught and then practiced. A leader is judged on the work and also on reading the room, executive presence and charisma. All three run on social cues, and all three can be taught.
The skill, talked through: in place of the word presence, a plan says what the leader will do that people will notice, the meeting where it counts, and where they try it first. Worked on a vice president of stores, and on how Uday learned to open with the one decision the board needed to make. Season 4, Episode 2.
Full transcript The episode as text · lightly cleaned for reading
"She's one of our strongest. She just needs to work on her executive presence."
You hear that at a talent review, about one of your best leaders. Everyone nods, and it goes into her development plan as it was said. Written down, that remark can harden into a verdict, that she lacks presence, as if it were something a leader either has or doesn't.
This episode is called “Lacks Executive Presence” Treats a Learnable Skill as a Trait.
This is The Autistic Leader Podcast. I'm Uday Kiran Bolusani. Each week, I take one piece of advice every leader already gives, and I give you one skill that makes it work for every kind of mind.
The people who give that advice are pointing at something real. A senior leader has to hold a board's attention, carry difficult news to a whole company, and get people to follow a decision once it's made.
Many of those people picked up presence by watching other senior leaders, and for many of them, that worked. So when you're sitting in that review, the thought in your head is simple: she's great, she'll grow into it. You mean that as help.
What does presence actually run on? To show you, I want to tell you about a talk I had with my son.
He's five, and right now he's learning jokes. We talked about how the same joke, told again and again, stops getting a laugh, and how a silly word he makes up can crack up his friends, even though the word on its own isn't a joke.
I tried to put all the rules of a joke into words for him, and I could barely do it. Those rules are really hard to write down.
What are they, actually? There's when to tell the joke, who to tell it to, and why it's funny at all. Those rules are about social cues, and a joke is only as good as those cues.
Comedic timing is one of those cues, and it's hard to pin down. The exact same words can get a big laugh from one group and silence from the next, because the cues around them are different.
Leadership runs on the same kind of unwritten rules. Those unwritten rules are what my work is about, and that talk handed me a simple way to explain them.
Leadership is ultimately influence. It's getting people to want to listen to you, and then to follow you. A leader gets judged on the work, but also on how they read the room, on their presence, and on their charisma. All three of those run on social cues, just like a joke does.
At work, the cues are what your executive team wants to hear first, and how much time they have. A comedian uses those cues to get a laugh. A leader uses the same cues to get people behind a decision. Using them well is the same kind of skill, put to a different end.
For me, that reading is something I do on purpose. I'm autistic, and social cues are one of the core differences in autism, though not the only one. A lot of people pick these up by feel. I work through them one by one, as they come. I notice things like a shift in someone's tone, a change in their posture, or how long they take to answer. Then I match what I see against patterns I've built up over years, from situations that went well and ones that went badly. That takes work every time.
Now think about where these skills get taught at work. Many organizations teach some of it to new managers. After that, they expect presence to already be there. That's a design choice, and your organization can make it differently.
Let's go back to that talent review, and to the person whose plan those words go into.
Say she's the vice president of stores at a home-furnishings retailer. She's the strongest operator you've got. In two years, she could be running operations.
Now, what does she do with that note?
On top of running every store, she's now trying to figure out what your executive team means by presence. That guessing is cognitive load. It's there because your organization has no process that teaches her what presence looks like at this level, the way it would teach her any other part of the job.
At the next monthly business review, she speaks louder and keeps her update short. That's her best reading of the word. No one on that team says whether she got it right, so she keeps guessing.
Meanwhile, you may never see the work she'd have done as head of operations.
Everyone in this story acted in good faith, the person who said she needed to work on her presence, and the people who nodded. The reason you might miss that work is how development is set up above the new-manager level.
So can presence be taught to senior leaders? Think about comedy. Its rules are hard to write down, as I found out with my son. But it's still a skill people learn, and then practice, over and over, before it counts.
In some stand-up classes, students write jokes, test them in every session, and get feedback. They can also try them at open mics, and some of those classes end with a showcase in front of an audience.
Some improv schools teach in a sequence. At one, you start with games and exercises, then build scenes and characters, and the final course ends in a show on one of the school's own stages. At another, a later course adds ways to bring the audience into the students' shows. The teaching keeps going, step by step.
Charisma is no different. In a study published in 2011, Antonakis and his colleagues trained middle managers and MBA students in what charismatic speakers do. Drawing on earlier research, they broke charisma down into moves you can see and practice. Telling a story is one. Setting up a contrast is another. Speaking with an animated voice is a third, and there were more.
They found that coworkers rated the trained managers as more charismatic than a group who didn't get the training.
But it took time. For the managers, the authors estimate at least 30 hours. For the students, 80 to 90 hours. They write that there are no quick fixes to learning leadership. They believe what mattered most was watching filmed examples, doing role-play, and getting feedback.
That study was about delivering a message, not reading a room. Still, the authors concluded that charisma is learnable. Like comedy, presence can be taught, and then practiced. So your organization can teach it to senior leaders, and give them a place to practice it.
Remember how the authors broke charisma down into moves? Here's a different move, one I had to learn myself.
In my career, I presented to fund boards, and I chaired a risk committee of chief investment officers. I'd open with the one decision the room needed to make, then bring only the facts it needed, inside the time we actually had.
I learned that the hard way. Early on, I'd sometimes give that senior audience more information than their time and attention allowed. I worked out the rule from those experiences, and since then, I've taught other leaders to open with the decision first.
That opening is one move, and a lot of what we call presence is built from small moves like that.
Here's the skill. In place of the word presence, a senior leader's development plan can carry three short lines: one thing they'll say or do that people will notice, the meeting where it counts and who's listening there, and where they try it first, with someone who gives them one piece of feedback.
Those three lines come from my Cognitive Translation Protocol. I built it so people who think differently aren't left to guess how their team communicates.
Take your vice president of stores again. At the monthly business review, she opens each update with the one decision she needs from your executive team, and one store she visited that shows why it matters, before any numbers. That's the one thing people will notice, and it makes her point stick.
That meeting is where it counts, because of who's in the room. Your executives and the regional directors have read the numbers before they walk in. They want to hear what she'd change. Speaking louder and shorter doesn't tell them that.
She doesn't try it first in that room, though. The day before, she runs her opening past a peer, who tells her one thing to change. If she stumbles there, that peer is the only one watching, and it does far less harm to how people see her as a leader.
Then the next talent review comes around. Her plan shows what she tried, and the feedback she got. Your executives talk about what she did at that business review. And she's still headed for the operations job.
Your part, as the executive who runs that review, is to bring that teaching and practice all the way up, starting with those three lines in a senior leader's plan. Once a plan says those three things, everyone can see what's being asked, and a leader whose mind works differently can prepare and practice for it. That opens your senior layers to more kinds of minds.
Let me sum it up. When a strong leader's plan says to work on her executive presence, it doesn't say what she should do, when, with whom, or why. She has to work out what the word means to your executive team. But like a joke, presence can be learned and practiced, at every level. In place of that one word, her plan says what she'll do that people notice, which meeting it's for and who's listening there, and where she tries it first, with someone who gives her feedback.
In this week's essay on my site, you'll find the vice president's three lines, ready to copy into a plan.
Here's my ask. I built this show to help leaders who think differently reach senior roles, by changing how organizations are designed. Every person who subscribes is one more leader this work reaches, every week. So subscribe to the Substack, and take each week's skill to your team.
And follow the show wherever you're listening. A follow brings you every new episode, and it helps more leaders who think differently find this work.
On Monday, find the word "presence" in the development plan of one leader who reports to you, or in your notes from the last talent review, and write the three lines in its place.